Cornell Japanese Animation Society Conquering Cornell through anime fandom

CJAS Alum quoted by MSNBC article on anime

General CJAS discussion

CJAS Alum quoted by MSNBC article on anime

Postby Jed » Wed Sep 17, 2008 10:24 am

Our own Lawrence Eng was quoted in this MSNBC article about how sexualized anime is going mainstream. I find the content of the article dubious. But, hey, it quotes a CJAS alum! :D
All glory to the Hypnotoad!
User avatar
Jed
E-board alum
 
Posts: 692

Re: CJAS Alum quoted by MSNBC article on anime

Postby Secretary Of Pocky » Wed Sep 17, 2008 12:24 pm

The article compares Gurren Lagann to Legend of the Overfiend. :shock:
"I love it when Masaaki Endoh shouts things. Attack names in particular, but he could shout just about anything and I'd be happy. When my mother passes, I want Endoh to deliver the news, so instead of getting sad I get really pumped about it."
User avatar
Secretary Of Pocky
E-board alum
 
Posts: 455

Re: CJAS Alum quoted by MSNBC article on anime

Postby Kathy Moon » Wed Sep 17, 2008 4:04 pm

Well, honestly, it's just missing a word. After "But sexually-suggestive and explicit anime like 'Gurren Lagann' and 'Legend of the Overfiend,' belongs the word "respectively". However, when the author called manga "graphic books", I wasn't sure if he meant "composed of graphic images" (drawings) or "containing graphic scenes" (R rated). Maybe he's not sure so he's hedging his bets?
"Unfortunately for you, we ARE that stupid!" - The Dai-Gurren Dan
User avatar
Kathy Moon
E-board alum
 
Posts: 87

Re: CJAS Alum quoted by MSNBC article on anime

Postby Mr. Sandman » Wed Sep 17, 2008 9:37 pm

Fascinating article. He's an expert; wow! That's cool. You know, back when I was 13 and started watching serious anime (Mononoke-Hime and such), Mom once sat me down and forbade me to watch hentai. She never used the specific words, but her meaning was clear. I guess she heard about alarm bell stories about how anime masquerade as innocent to obfuscate their hidden hentai.

Funny story: Before they realized what was on the disc, I remember seeing Neon Genesis Evangelion: Death and Rebirth in the Cartoons section at my local Blockbuster. Mind you, this was when it was first released, so many people didn't know better... But still...
*sigh* Dispatched, in mankind's darkest hour, we are Knights of the Blue Flame.

けー… 我々は, 終末の日に遣わされた白日の使徒にして, 蒼炎の騎士だ。
User avatar
Mr. Sandman
E-board alum
 
Posts: 84

Re: CJAS Alum quoted by MSNBC article on anime

Postby Mike » Thu Sep 18, 2008 12:03 am

At least Lawrence's quotes are trust-worthy and accurate. I can't say that about the rest of the article, though I've seen much worse.
Mike
E-board alum
 
Posts: 209

Re: CJAS Alum quoted by MSNBC article on anime

Postby W-General » Thu Sep 18, 2008 8:55 pm

I would like to applaud Lawrence our good Alum for setting things right about Lolicon.

Whatever it is, for a true otaku, Eng says, it [lolicon] is not pedophilia. “Fans abhor young looking [real-life] models,” he said. “They abhor real child porn. They do not want to be associated with that stuff.”

For example, on a Lolicon chat board recently, someone posted a Japanese DVD cover showing real schoolgirls, around 8 years old, dressed in uniforms, showing their panties, smiling, giggling. The community was outraged and urged harsh punishment for the makers of the DVD, arguing that there is a vast and important difference between “2-D” and “3-D.”


Remember, folks.
Lolicon != pedophile or sexual predator.

Two dimensional drawings: good.
Real little girls: bad. Say no to CP!
撃っていいのは、撃たれる覚悟があるやつだけだ。
俺は世界を壊し、世界を作る...
My anime blog: http://wgeneral.wordpress.com
My anime list: http://myanimelist.net/animelist/W-General
User avatar
W-General
E-board alum
 
Posts: 131

Re: CJAS Alum quoted by MSNBC article on anime

Postby Jed » Mon Sep 22, 2008 10:38 am

Here's Lawrence's own response to (a podcast's response to) the article.
All glory to the Hypnotoad!
User avatar
Jed
E-board alum
 
Posts: 692

Re: CJAS Alum quoted by MSNBC article on anime

Postby TheBigN » Mon Sep 29, 2008 11:48 am

Mike wrote:At least Lawrence's quotes are trust-worthy and accurate. I can't say that about the rest of the article, though I've seen much worse.


Pretty much. As someone else on another forum I go to mentioned, it was like the article was trying to say "Hey! Here's this fun area of fetishes to try!" more than anything else. It irks me a little though.
User avatar
TheBigN
E-board alum
 
Posts: 17


Return to General discussion

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 0 guests

cron